List of Major League Baseball career fielding errors as a center fielder leaders

Tris Speaker, the modern leader in fielding errors as a center fielder

In baseball statistics, an error is an act, in the judgment of the official scorer, of a fielder misplaying a ball in a manner that allows a batter or baserunner to advance one or more bases or allows an at bat to continue after the batter should have been put out. The center fielder (CF) is one of the three outfielders, the defensive positions in baseball farthest from the batter. Center field is the area of the outfield directly in front of a person standing at home plate and facing beyond the pitcher's mound. The outfielders' duty is to try to catch long fly balls before they hit the ground or to quickly catch or retrieve and return to the infield any other balls entering the outfield. Generally having the most territory to cover, the center fielder is usually the fastest of the three outfielders, although this can also depend on the relative strength of their throwing arms and the configuration of their home field, due to the deepest part of center field being the farthest point from the infield and home plate. The center fielder normally plays behind the shortstop and second baseman, who play in or near the infield; unlike catchers and most infielders (excepting first basemen), who are virtually exclusively right-handed, center fielders can be either right- or left-handed. In the scoring system used to record defensive plays, the center fielder is assigned the number 8.

The list of career leaders is dominated by players from the early 20th century; only three of the top 25 players were active after 1953. Only nine of the top 71 single-season totals were recorded after 1927, only one after 1939; only five of the top 183 totals were recorded after 1964. To a large extent, the leaders reflect longevity rather than lower skill. Tris Speaker, who holds the modern (post-1900) record of 227 errors committed as a center fielder, is often regarded as the greatest outfielder in history, setting records for putouts and assists; Willie Mays, whose 139 errors are the most by a center fielder since 1930, won twelve Gold Glove Awards for defensive excellence.

Because game accounts and box scores often did not distinguish between the outfield positions, there has been some difficulty in determining precise defensive statistics prior to 1901; because of this, and because of the similarity in their roles, defensive statistics for the three positions are frequently combined. Although efforts to distinguish between the three positions regarding games played during this period and reconstruct the separate totals have been largely successful, separate error totals are unavailable; players whose totals are missing the figures for pre-1901 games are notated in the table below. Tris Speaker is the post-1900 leader in career errors committed as a center fielder with 227; Ty Cobb (208) is second, and is the only other center fielder to commit over 200 career errors. Lorenzo Cain, who had 39 errors through the 2022 season to place him tied for 130th all-time, is the leader among active players.

Key[edit]

Rank Rank amongst leaders in career errors committed. A blank field indicates a tie.
Player Name of player
E as CF Total career errors committed as a center fielder
* Denotes elected to National Baseball Hall of Fame
Denotes total is missing figures for pre-1901 games

List[edit]

Andrew McCutchen, the active leader and tied for 140th all-time in errors as a center fielder
Max Carey holds the modern National League record.
Rank Player E as LF
1 Tris Speaker * 227
2 Ty Cobb * 208
3 Clyde Milan 192
4 Max Carey * 179
5 Cy Seymour 143
6 Willie Mays * 139
7 Edd Roush * 134
8 Earl Averill * 122
9 Willie Davis 121
10 Dode Paskert 111
11 Richie Ashburn * 106
Doc Cramer 106
13 Cy Williams 102
14 Joe DiMaggio * 100
15 Ginger Beaumont 99
16 Rebel Oakes 92
Burt Shotton 92
18 Sam Chapman 91
19 Taylor Douthit 90
20 Dom DiMaggio 89
21 Earle Combs * 88
22 Hi Myers 87
23 Baby Doll Jacobson 86
24 Hack Wilson * 84
25 Sam Rice * 80
26 Kenny Lofton 78
Willie McGee 78
Lloyd Waner * 78
29 Bill Bruton 77
Johnny Mostil 77
Vada Pinson 77
Ray Powell 77
33 Ken Griffey Jr. * 76
Garry Maddox 76
35 Benny Kauff 75
Tilly Walker 75
37 Sam West 72
38 Wally Berger 71
Fred Schulte 71
40 Johnny Bates 70
Ron LeFlore 70
Bill Virdon 70
43 Mickey Mantle * 67
Homer Smoot 67
Roy Thomas 67
46 Tommy Leach 66
47 Joe Birmingham 65
Rick Monday 65
Devon White 65
50 Mike Cameron 64
Chick Stahl 64
Rank Player E as LF
52 Steve Finley 63
Charlie Hemphill 63
Danny Hoffman 63
55 Jimmy Barrett 61
Emmet Heidrick 61
57 Carlos Beltrán 60
58 Tommie Agee 59
Lance Johnson 59
60 Marquis Grissom 58
Chet Lemon 58
Jack Smith 58
Duke Snider * 58
64 Vince DiMaggio 57
Mike Kreevich 57
Nemo Leibold 57
Fred Snodgrass 57
68 Adam Jones 56
Fielder Jones 56
Omar Moreno 56
Jigger Statz 56
72 Ben Chapman 55
Mickey Rivers 55
74 César Cedeño 54
Kiki Cuyler * 54
Jim Edmonds 54
Curt Flood 54
Billy North 54
Turkey Stearnes * 54 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Jimmy Wynn 54
81 Paul Blair 53
82 John Dobbs 52
83 Vin Campbell 51
Happy Felsch 51
Harry Rice 51
86 Ping Bodie 50
Larry Doby * 50
Rick Manning 50
Lloyd Moseby 50
90 Dave Fultz 49
Fred Lynn 49
92 Terry Moore 48
Reggie Smith 48
Amos Strunk 48
95 Al Simmons * 47
Jo-Jo White 47
Bernie Williams 47
98 Andre Dawson * 46
Ira Flagstead 46
Cliff Heathcote 46
Dwayne Murphy 46
Gee Walker 46

Other Hall of Famers[edit]

Player E Other leagues, notes
MLB American League National League
Kirby Puckett* 42 42 0
Oscar Charleston* 38 0 0 Includes incomplete Negro league totals
Cool Papa Bell* 36 0 0 Includes incomplete Negro league totals
Sam Crawford* † 31 31 0
Billy Southworth* 26 4 22
Robin Yount* 25 25 0
Rickey Henderson* 24 22 2
Casey Stengel* 24 0 24
Chick Hafey* 22 0 22
Heinie Manush* 22 22 0
Willard Brown* 21 0 0 Includes incomplete Negro league totals
Roger Bresnahan* † 20 5 15
Cristóbal Torriente* 16 0 0 Includes incomplete Negro league totals

References[edit]