Temporada | Semifinal (1° etapa) | Semifinal (2° etapa) | Final |
2004–05 | Sheffield Wednesday 1–0 Brentford Hartlepool United 2–0 Tranmere Rovers | Brentford 1–2 Sheffield Wednesday Tranmere Rovers 2–0 Hartlepool United (Hartlepool venceu por 6–5 nos pênaltis) | Sheffield Wednesday 4–2 Hartlepool United (a.e.t.) |
2005–06 | Barnsley 0–1 Huddersfield Town Swansea City 1–1 Brentford | Huddersfield Town 1–3 Barnsley Brentford 0–2 Swansea City | Barnsley 2–2 Swansea City (Barnsley venceu por 4–3 nos pênaltis) |
2006–07 | Yeovil Town 0–2 Nottingham Forest Oldham Athletic 1–2 Blackpool | Nottingham Forest 2–5 Yeovil Town (a.e.t.) Blackpool 3–1 Oldham Athletic | Blackpool 2–0 Yeovil Town |
2007–08 | Southend United 0–0 Doncaster Rovers Leeds United 1–2 Carlisle United | Doncaster Rovers 5–1 Southend United Carlisle United 0–2 Leeds United | Leeds United 0–1 Doncaster Rovers |
2008–09 | Scunthorpe United 1–1 Milton Keynes Dons Millwall 1–0 Leeds United | Milton Keynes Dons 0–0 Scunthorpe United (Scunthorpe venceu por 7–6 nos pênaltis) Leeds United 1–1 Millwall | Scunthorpe United 3–2 Millwall |
2009–10 | Swindon Town 2–1 Charlton Athletic Huddersfield Town 0–0 Millwall | Charlton Athletic 2–1 Swindon Town (Swindon venceu por 5–4 nos pênaltis) Millwall 2–0 Huddersfield Town | Millwall 1–0 Swindon Town |
2010–11 | Bournemouth 1–1 Huddersfield Town Milton Keynes Dons 3–2 Peterborough United | Huddersfield Town 3–3 Bournemouth (Huddersfield venceu por 4–2 nos pênaltis) Peterborough United 2–0 Milton Keynes Dons | Huddersfield Town 0–3 Peterborough United |
2011–12 | Stevenage 0–0 Sheffield United Milton Keynes Dons 0–2 Huddersfield Town | Sheffield United 1–0 Stevenage Huddersfield Town 1–2 Milton Keynes Dons | Huddersfield Town 0–0 Sheffield United (Huddersfield venceu por 8–7 nos pênaltis) |
2012–13 | Sheffield United 1–0 Yeovil Town Swindon Town 1–1 Brentford | Yeovil Town 2–0 Sheffield United Brentford 3–3 Swindon Town (Brentford venceu por 5–4 nos pênaltis) | Brentford 1–2 Yeovil Town |
2013–14 | Peterborough United 1–1 Leyton Orient Preston North End 1–1 Rotherham United | Leyton Orient 2–1 Peterborough United Rotherham United 3–1 Preston North End | Leyton Orient 2–2 Rotherham United (Rotherham venceu por 4–3 nos pênaltis) |
2014–15 | Chesterfield 0–1 Preston North End Sheffield United 1–2 Swindon Town | Preston North End 3–0 Chesterfield Swindon Town 5–5 Sheffield United | Preston North End 4–0 Swindon Town |
2015–16 | Barnsley 3–0 Walsall Bradford City 1–3 Millwall | Walsall 1–3 Barnsley Millwall 1–1 Bradford City | Barnsley 3–1 Millwall |
2016–17 | Millwall 0–0 Scunthorpe United Bradford City 1–0 Fleetwood Town | Scunthorpe United 2–3 Millwall Fleetwood Town 0–0 Bradford City | Bradford City 0–1 Millwall |
2017–18 | Charlton Athletic 0–1 Shrewsbury Town Scunthorpe United 2–2 Rotherham United | Shrewsbury Town 1–0 Charlton Athletic Rotherham United 2–0 Scunthorpe United | Rotherham United 2–1 Shrewsbury Town (a.e.t.) |
2018–19 | Sunderland 1–0 Portsmouth Doncaster Rovers 1–2 Charlton Athletic | Portsmouth 0–0 Sunderland Charlton Athletic 2–3 Doncaster Rovers (Charlton venceu por 4–3 nos pênaltis) | Charlton Athletic 2–1 Sunderland |